Sunday, 5 January 2014

The Beatles' US Capitol Albums: An Overview

After The Beatles finally broke the US market in the closing days of December 1963, their music was repackaged by Capitol for the American audience. Although they did not like this butchering of their work, neither The Beatles nor George Martin had any control over Capitol’s releases. Indeed, they were complicit (albeit reluctantly) in their release, on several occasions recording or mixing songs specifically at Capitol’s request in order to flesh out forthcoming albums.

Regardless of The Beatles’ feelings on the matter, there are two historically accurate points to make about Capitol’s releases:

1) Capitol’s late embrace of The Beatles combined with their large output of material between 1963 and 1966 meant that they were able to release 10 albums in the 31 months between January 1964 (Meet The Beatles) and August 1966 (Revolver), compared with only 5 released during the same period in the UK. During this period, United Artists also released the soundtrack to A Hard Day's Night.

2) The Capitol albums were how The Beatles were heard in America until their catalogue was formalised to the UK releases in 1987. America was, and remains, The Beatles’ biggest market.

This article does not seek to criticize or demonize Capitol’s treatment of The Beatles’ early catalogue. Rather it intends to document the differences from their UK output, and place it within a historical context.
The original picture sleeve for Capitol's first Beatles
single, "I Want To Hold Your Hand"
(Capitol 5112, 
26 December 1963)

The track that opened up the American market to The Beatles was I Want To Hold Your Hand, released 17 days ahead of schedule on 26 December 1963, due to huge radio airplay and subsequent demand. There had been 3 US singles and an album prior to this, but none of them had been released on Capitol, and none of them had made any impact.

Capitol went on to release 13 uniquely American albums of The Beatles’ music, as follows:

The content of the albums was determined by several factors:

First and foremost was the difference between UK and US royalty payment calculations. In the UK, payments were made on a per disc basis, with each publisher receiving a pro-rata payment on royalties based on album sales. In the US, on the other hand, payments were made on a per song basis. Therefore, in the US, each extra song on an album cost the record company money. In order to reduce costs, US albums consisted of fewer songs as a matter of cost.

Dave Dexter Jr.
A second factor was a cultural one. Parlophone, the Beatles' record label in the UK, routinely left singles off albums, so that fans were not being asked to purchase the same recording on two different formats. In the US, it was believed that an album which contained hit singles would sell more than an album which did not. Therefore, singles were routinely included on albums. Related to this was the decline of the EP in the US. The Beatles released two EPs of non-album material in the UK, neither of which was released in the US.

In understanding the difference between The Beatles UK and US releases, it is important to understand a couple of technical terms. These are mixing and mastering. Mixing is the process of combining all of the individual sounds that make up a recording into one mono or stereo recording. Almost all of the music recorded by The Beatles was mixed by George Martin, or in later years, The Beatles themselves, at EMI's Abbey Road studios, in London. This includes all of the music released in the US. Mastering is the process of taking the finished set of recordings and preparing them for release. This means that all of the tracks on a record are of a similar volume, and have a similar frequency response across the audio spectrum. Sometimes reverb may be added as well. Mastering was done separately at Parlophone in the UK and at Capitol in the US.

The Beatles albums up to and including Rubber Soul were compiled for Capitol under the direction of A&R man, Dave Dexter Jr. Dexter felt that George Martin's mixes were too British, dry and lacking in excitement, so in many cases he mastered the tracks supplied to him by Parlophone to beef up the high end of the sound, and added reverb, giving the songs a more American sound. Dexter's sonic decisions have come in for much criticism over the years, not least by The Beatles themselves, but those decisions were made for sound commercial reasons at the time. Dexter's job was to sell The Beatles to America. If that meant making them more palatable to American tastes, then so be it. History tells us that it worked. Whether they would have been as successful in the US without Dexter's mastering decisions can never be known.

A third factor was that some tracks were not available for Capitol to use. Because they had opted not to release The Beatles’ early singles, Epstein had licensed them to a small label called VeeJay, who released them with very limited success, and in the case of the She Loves You single, a label called Swan.

This was all part of Capitol’s marketing strategy to sell as much content to the fans as possible, and there can be no argument that the strategy worked

As was common practice in the 1960s, the albums were released in both mono and stereo formats. Stereo was still a secondary consideration in the UK, and because of Capitol's rushed release schedule, sometimes only a mono mix was available. Similarly, where Capitol wanted to include a UK single on an album, there was usually no stereo mix at all. Where this was the case, a fake stereo mix - known as a "duophonic" mix -  was created from the mono mix by running it through two channels, boosting the bass in one channel and the treble in the other, and running the two channels slightly out of sync. Sometimes reverb was added as well.

The reverse was also true. Rather than use the true mono mixes supplied by Parlophone, Capitol created fake mono mixes - known as fold-downs, or Type B mono - from the stereo mixes by combining the left and right channels together, in the belief that it would create a punchier sound.

Each time tweaks were made to the sound, a new copy had to be made, meaning that Capitol's US master tapes were second, third or even fourth generation copies of Parlophone's UK masters.

The demand from the US for new material from The Beatles was such that producer George Martin often had to mix tracks from albums that they were still working on. These would be immediately dispatched to Capitol, where they would be released on an album within a few weeks. Martin would often create newer, better mixes for release in the UK. For this reason, the US albums contained 25 songs where the mixes differed from their UK equivalent. These are:

  • You Can't Do That (mono)
  • Long Tall Sally (mono)
  • Long Tall Sally (stereo)
  • I Call Your Name (mono)
  • I Call Your Name (stereo)
  • And I Love Her (mono)
  • I'll Cry Instead (mono)
  • Any Time At All (mono)
  • When I Get Home (mono)
  • I'll Be Back (mono)
  • I'll Be Back (stereo)
  • Komm, Gibb Mir Deine Hand (stereo)
  • I Feel Fine (mono)
  • She's A Woman (mono)
  • Day Tripper (stereo)
  • We Can Work It Out (stereo)
  • The Word (stereo)
  • Michelle (mono)
  • I'm Looking Through You (stereo)
  • I'm Only Sleeping (mono)
  • I'm Only Sleeping (stereo)
  • And Your Bird Can Sing (mono)
  • And Your Bird Can Sing (stereo)
  • Dr. Robert (mono)
  • Dr. Robert (stereo)

Additionally, the US A Hard Day's Night and Help! soundtrack albums contained a number of orchestral tracks that were not released in the UK. These were:

  • I Should Have Known Better
  • And I Love Her
  • Ringo's Theme (This Boy)
  • A Hard Day's Night
  • Help! (intro)
  • From Me to You Fantasy
  • In the Tyrol
  • Another Hard Day's Night
  • Medley: The Bitter End /You Can't Do That
  • The Chase


The first eight of The Beatles' US albums - those compiled by Dave Dexter - were remastered and released on CD in two box sets:
The image used in the promotion of The Beatles' US Albums box set

A complete set of The Beatles' US albums (excluding Magical Mystery Tour, which was incorporated into the core catalogue in 1987, but adding the 1964 documentary album, The Beatles Story) is also available. While maintaining the original tracklistings, in order to provide the best possible sound quality, these versions of the albums dispense with Dexter's fake mono and stereo masters, which were often copies of copies of the UK master tapes. Dexter's work has instead been recreated digitally using the true mono and stereo masters released in 2009 as a basis.[1]

A Guide to the Mono and Stereo Editions of The Beatles US Albums

The information below is taken from:


Meet The Beatles

Meet The Beatles was released in mono (T-2047) and stereo (ST-2047) versions by Capitol on 20 January 1964. It featured the same artwork as The Beatles’ contemporary UK album, With the Beatles: Robert Freeman’s striking black and white half shadowed faces.

The album contained 12 songs, instead of the 14 on With The Beatles:

Side One
1. I Want to Hold Your Hand
2. I Saw Her Standing There
3. This Boy
4. It Won't Be Long
5. All I've Got to Do
6. All My Loving

Side Two
1. Don't Bother Me
2. Little Child
3. Till There Was You
4. Hold Me Tight
5. I Wanna Be Your Man
6. Not a Second Time


Musically, it kicked off with The Beatles recent hit single, I Want To Hold Your Hand, and its B-side, I Saw Her Standing There. The single’s UK B-side, This Boy, was the third track. Thereafter, it contains all of the Beatles originals from With The Beatles, in the same order as they appear on the UK album, along with the album’s only cover, Till There Was You.

The stereo versions of I Want To Hold Your Hand and This Boy were duophonic (fake stereo) versions created from the UK mono mixes, as stereo versions of these tracks had not been made available to Capitol (although stereo versions of both songs had been made at Abbey Road in October 1963, neither had yet been released in the UK). The remaining stereo tracks are the same mixes as the stereo version of With The Beatles.

The mono album was created using fake mono fold downs of the stereo mixes, except for I Want To Hold Your Hand and This Boy, which used the genuine mono mixes.

I Want to Hold Your Hand
Mono: as per UK single from mono mix of 21 October 1963
Stereo: fake stereo from mono mix of 21 October 1963

I Saw Her Standing There
Mono: fake mono from UK stereo mix of 25 February 1963
Stereo: as per stereo mix of 25 February 1963

This Boy
Mono: as per UK single from mono mix of 21 October 1963
Stereo: fake stereo from mono mix of 21 October 1963

It Won't Be Long
Mono: fake mono from UK stereo mix of 29 October 1963
Stereo: as per stereo mix of 29 October 1963

All I've Got to Do
Mono: fake mono from UK stereo mix of 29 October 1963
Stereo: as per stereo mix of 29 October 1963

All My Loving
Mono: fake mono from UK stereo mix of 29 October 1963
Stereo: as per stereo mix of 29 October 1963

Don't Bother Me
Mono: fake mono from UK stereo mix of 29 October 1963
Stereo: as per stereo mix of 29 October 1963

Little Child
Mono: fake mono from UK stereo mix of 29 October 1963
Stereo: as per stereo mix of 29 October 1963

Till There Was You
Mono: fake mono from UK stereo mix of 29 October 1963
Stereo: as per stereo mix of 29 October 1963

Hold Me Tight
Mono: fake mono from UK stereo mix of 29 October 1963
Stereo: as per stereo mix of 29 October 1963

I Wanna Be Your Man
Mono: fake mono from UK stereo mix of 29 October 1963
Stereo: as per stereo mix of 29 October 1963

Not a Second Time
Mono: fake mono from UK stereo mix of 29 October 1963
Stereo: as per stereo mix of 29 October 1963


The Beatles’ Second Album

The Beatles' Second Album was released in mono (T-2080) and stereo (ST-2080) by Capitol on 10 April 1964, just over 2½ months after its predecessor. The artwork was compiled from a collection of publicity photographs.

Side One
1. Roll Over Beethoven
2. Thank You Girl
3. You Really Got a Hold on Me
4. Devil in Her Heart
5. Money (That's What I Want)
6. You Can't Do That

Side Two
1. Long Tall Sally
2. I Call Your Name
3. Please Mister Postman
4. I'll Get You
5. She Loves You



This album has been called the best pure rock’n’roll album The Beatles ever released. In reality, it is Capitol’s first cut and paste job of The Beatles’ material. Side one contains 4 of the remaining 5 cover tracks from With The Beatles, plus the B-sides of the singles From Me To You and Can’t Buy Me Love. Side two contains two tracks from the forthcoming UK Long Tall Sally EP, the remaining cover from With The Beatles, and both sides of The Beatles’ single, She Loves You.

Like its predecessor, the mono version of The Beatles’ Second Album is a hodge-podge of UK mono mixes and fold-down mono. She Loves You and I'll Get You are the UK mono mixes. You Can't Do ThatI Call Your Name and Long Tall Sally are also genuine mono, but are different mixes from the UK mono versions, prepared by George Martin specifically for the US. The rest of the songs are folddowns.

The songs on the stereo album have significantly more echo than those on the mono album or the British versions of the songs. Thank-You Girl is a US exclusive stereo mix, as only the mono mix was available in the UK, although it was brought into the core catalogue when it was released on Past Masters in 2009. I Call Your Name and Long Tall Sally are also genuine stereo, prepared by George Martin specifically for the US. Neither of these mixes are part of the core catalogue - the 1976's Rock and Roll Music used alternative stereo mixes, as did 1988's Past Masters.

Roll Over Beethoven
Mono: fake mono from UK stereo mix of 29 October 1963
Stereo: as per stereo mix of 29 October 1963

Thank You Girl
Mono: fake mono from stereo mix of 13 March 1963
Stereo: as per stereo mix of 13 March 1963

You Really Got a Hold on Me
Mono: fake mono from UK stereo mix of 29 October 1963
Stereo: as per stereo mix of 29 October 1963

Devil in Her Heart
Mono: fake mono from UK stereo mix of 29 October 1963
Stereo: as per stereo mix of 29 October 1963

Money (That's What I Want)
Mono: fake mono from UK stereo mix of 30 October 1963
Stereo: as per stereo mix of 30 October 1963

You Can't Do That
Mono: US exclusive mono mix of 26 February1964
Stereo: fake stereo from US exclusive mono mix of 26 February1964

Long Tall Sally
Mono: US exclusive mono mix of 10 March 1964
Stereo: US exclusive stereo mix of 10 March 1964

I Call Your Name
Mono: US exclusive mono mix of 4 March 1964
Stereo: US exclusive stereo mix of 10 March 1964

Please Mister Postman
Mono: fake mono from UK stereo mix of 29 October 1963
Stereo: as per stereo mix of 29 October 1963

I'll Get You
Mono: as per UK single from mono mix of 4 July 1963
Stereo: fake stereo from mono mix of 4 July 1963

She Loves You
Mono: as per UK single from mono mix of 4 July 1963
Stereo: fake stereo from mono mix of 4 July 1963



A Hard Day's Night [Original Motion Picture Soundtrack]

The soundtrack album to The Beatles' first film, A Hard Day's Night, was released in mono (UA 6366) and stereo (UAS 6366) by United Artists on 26 June 1964. The album was reissued by Capitol on 17 August 1980 (SW-11921) after EMI acquired United Artists Records.

Side one
1. A Hard Day's Night
2. Tell Me Why
3. I'll Cry Instead
4. I Should Have Known Better (Instrumental)
5. I'm Happy Just to Dance with You
6. And I Love Her (Instrumental)

Side two
1. I Should Have Known Better
2. If I Fell
3. And I Love Her
4. Ringo's Theme (This Boy) (Instrumental)
5. Can't Buy Me Love
6. A Hard Day's Night (Instrumental)


As this album was not released by Capitol, it was not compiled by Dave Dexter. It consists of the seven songs from side 1 of the UK album, plus a US exclusive extended version of I'll Cry Instead. Interspersed with these are four orchestral versions of Beatles songs, scored by George Martin, taken from the film's soundtrack.

All of the tracks on the mono version of the album are in genuine mono, and are the same as the UK mono release, with the exception of I'll Cry Instead, which includes an extra verse, and And I Love Her; an earlier mono mix, distinguishable by McCartney's vocal, which is mostly single tracked.

While the stereo version of the album contains genuine stereo mixes of George Martin's instrumental tracks, The Beatles' songs are in fake stereo. Most of the songs would get a genuine stereo release on the band's next Capitol album, Something New, but I Should Have Known Better and Can't Buy Me Love would not be released in stereo in the US until 1970's Hey Jude, and A Hard Day's Night itself remained unreleased in stereo until 1982's Reel Music.

The same fake stereo master tape was used when the album was reissued by Capitol in 1980.

A Hard Day's Night
Mono: mono mix of 23 April 1964
Stereo: fake stereo from mono mix of 23 April 1964

Tell Me Why
Mono: mono mix of 3 March 1964
Stereo: fake stereo from mono mix of 3 March 1964

I'll Cry Instead
Mono: US exclusive mono mix of 4 June 1964.
Stereo: fake stereo from US exclusive mono mix of 4 June 1964

I'm Happy Just to Dance with You
Mono: mono mix of 3 March 1964
Stereo: fake stereo from mono mix of 3 March 1964

I Should Have Known Better
Mono: mono mix of 3 March 1964
Stereo: fake stereo from mono mix of 3 March 1964

If I Fell
Mono: mono mix of 3 March 1964
Stereo: fake stereo from mono mix of 3 March 1964

And I Love Her
Mono: US exclusive mono mix of 3 March 1964
Stereo: fake stereo from mono mix of 3 March 1964

Can't Buy Me Love
Mono: mono mix of 26 February 1964
Stereo: fake stereo from mono mix of 26 February 1964



Something New

The Beatles' third Capitol album, Something New, was released in mono (T-2108) and stereo (ST-2108) on 20 July 1964, just over three months since it's predecessor, and only one month after United Artists released the A Hard Day's Night soundtrack.

Side One
1. I'll Cry Instead
2. Things We Said Today
3. Any Time at All
4. When I Get Home
5. Slow Down
6. Matchbox

Side Two
1. Tell Me Why
2. And I Love Her
3. I'm Happy Just to Dance with You
4. If I Fell
5. Komm, Gib Mir Deine Hand



It wasn't quite as new as it's title suggested. By this time Capitol were struggling to find new material to release. Five of Something New's eleven songs had already been released the previous month on the A Hard Day's Night soundtrack. Of the remaining six, three were taken from the UK version of A Hard Day's Night , two from the Long Tall Sally EP, and the last, somewhat inexplicably, was the German language version of I Want To Hold Your Hand.

The mono version of the album uses the same mono tracks previously released by United Artists, including the extended version of I'll Cry Instead and the US version of And I Love Her. Any Time At All and When I Get Home were mixed in mono specifically for Capitol by George Martin. Komm, Gib Mir Deine Hand used a mono mix created by Martin for the German market, but which was unreleased in the UK until 1978's Rarities. The remaining mono mixes were identical to the UK releases.

The stereo version of Something New was the first US Beatles album to be released entirely in true stereo. The mixes were identical to the songs used on the UK version of A Hard Day's Night, with the exception of Matchbox and Slow Down, mixed into stereo specifically for Capitol by Martin. These remained unreleased in the UK until 1976's Rock and Roll MusicKomm, Gib Mir Deine Hand used a stereo mix created by Martin for the German market and was unreleased in the UK until 1988's Past Masters.

This created an anomaly. I'll Cry Instead was created by editing two different takes together. George Martin had mixed the mono version of I'll Cry Instead on 4 June 1964, and sent it off to Capitol and United Artists the day after. The stereo mix was created on 22 June, and sent off to Capitol very soon after - probably the following day. It wasn't until after this - probably while compiling the mono and stereo versions of the UK version of A Hard Day's Night - that it was discovered that a mistake had been made while editing the stereo mix, and a verse had been inadvertently left out when the two takes were edited together. With the album release imminent, Martin chose to edit the extra verse out of the mono mix instead of remixing a longer stereo version. It was too late to change the US releases, but the UK mixes are both the shorter version. The longer mono mix appears on the US A Hard Day's Night (in both mono and fake stereo versions), and on the mono version of Something New, while the stereo version of Something New contains the shorter stereo mix.

I'll Cry Instead
Mono: US Exclusive mono mix of 4 June 1964.
Stereo: stereo mix of 22 June 1964

Things We Said Today
Mono: mono mix of 4 June 1964.
Stereo: stereo mix of 22 June 1964

Any Time at All
Mono:  US exclusive mono mix of 22 June 1964
Stereo: stereo mix of 22 June 1964

When I Get Home
Mono:  US exclusive mono mix of 22 June 1964
Stereo: stereo mix of 22 June 1964

Slow Down
Mono: mono mix of 4 June 1964.
Stereo: stereo mix of 22 June 1964

Matchbox
Mono: mono mix of 4 June 1964.
Stereo: stereo mix of 22 June 1964

Tell Me Why
Mono: mono mix of 3 March 1964
Stereo: stereo mix of 22 June 1964

And I Love Her
Mono:  US exclusive mono mix of 3 March 1964
Stereo: stereo mix of 22 June 1964

I'm Happy Just to Dance with You
Mono: mono mix of 3 March 1964
Stereo: stereo mix of 22 June 1964

If I Fell
Mono: mono mix of 3 March 1964
Stereo: stereo mix of 22 June 1964

Komm, Gib Mir Deine Hand
Mono: mono mix of 10 March 1964.
Stereo: stereo mix of 12 March 1964



Beatles '65

Beatles '65 was released in mono (T-2228) and stereo (ST-2228) by Capitol on 15 December 1964.

Side One
1. No Reply
2. I'm a Loser
3. Baby's in Black
4. Rock and Roll Music
5. I'll Follow the Sun
6. Mr. Moonlight

Side Two
1. Honey Don't
2. I'll Be Back
3. She's a Woman
4. I Feel Fine
5. Everybody's Trying to Be My Baby



It was Capitol's version of the UK Beatles For Sale album, compiled, as usual, by Dave Dexter Jr. Side one followed the same track listing as side one of the UK album, missing only the final song, to cut the side down to the standard six tracks. Side two was a mish-mash, using two more songs from Beatles For Sale, the final song from the UK version of A Hard Day's Night, and the two sides of The Beatles' latest single.

All the tracks taken from Beatles For Sale used the same mixes as the UK in both mono and stereo versions of the album. I'll Be Back, the one remaining unreleased song from A Hard Day's Night, had received a US mono mix by George Martin while mixing that album, but wasn't released until now. He had also created US specific mono mixes of both sides of The Beatles' latest single, I Feel Fine and She's A Woman.

The UK stereo mix of I'll Be Back was used on the stereo version of the album, but as I Feel Fine and She's A Woman were intended for single release, no stereo mixes had been prepared. Dexter created fake stereo versions of both, but in what is arguably the only time his work was actually detrimental to the Beatles' sound, he drenched both tracks in reverb.

No Reply
Mono: mono mix of 16 October 1964
Stereo: stereo mix of 4 November 1964

I'm a Loser
Mono: mono mix of 26 October 1964
Stereo: stereo mix of 4 November 1964

Baby's in Black
Mono: mono mix of 26 October 1964
Stereo: stereo mix of 4 November 1964

Rock and Roll Music
Mono: mono mix of 26 October 1964
Stereo: stereo mix of 4 November 1964

I'll Follow the Sun
Mono: mono mix of 21 October 1964
Stereo: stereo mix of 4 November 1964

Mr. Moonlight
Mono: mono mix of 27 October 1964
Stereo: stereo mix of 27 October 1964

Honey Don't
Mono: mono mix of 21 October 1964
Stereo: stereo mix of 4 November 1964

I'll Be Back
Mono: US exclusive mono mix of 22 June 1964
Stereo: stereo mix of 22 June 1964

She's a Woman
Mono: US exclusive mono mix of 21 October 1964
Stereo: fake stereo from mono mix of 21 October 1964

I Feel Fine
Mono: US exclusive mono mix of 21 October 1964
Stereo: fake stereo from mono mix of 21 October 1964

Everybody's Trying to Be My Baby
Mono: mono mix of 21 October 1964
Stereo: stereo mix of 4 November 1964



The Early Beatles

The Early Beatles was released by Capitol in Mono (T-2309) and stereo (ST-2309) on 22 March 1965. The artwork was a picture previously used on the rear cover of The Beatles most recent UK album, Beatles For Sale.

Side One
1. Love Me Do
2. Twist and Shout
3. Anna (Go to Him)
4. Chains
5. Boys
6. Ask Me Why

Side Two
1. Please Please Me 
2. P.S. I Love You
3. Baby It's You
4. A Taste of Honey
5. Do You Want to Know a Secret



But this was not a new Beatles album as such. It was simply Capitol's repackaging of The Beatles' two year old UK debut album, Please Please Me . All of the tracks had been released previously in the US by Chicago-based independent label, VeeJay, who had acquired the rights to 16 of The Beatles early recordings after Capitol declined to release them. These were the fourteen songs on the Please Please Me album, along with From Me To You, and its B side, Thank You Girl. Following a legal dispute (during which Capitol cheekily released I Saw Her Standing There on Meet The Beatles, and Thank You Girl on The Beatles' Second Album), Capitol regained ownership on 15 October 1964.

The Early Beatles was simply a means of keeping The Beatles' early material commercially available, now that VeeJay could no longer distribute it. Nevertheless, this album, compiled again by Dave Dexter Jr., stuck to Capitol's now standard eleven songs per album, rendering three of The Beatles' early recordings commercially unavailable in the US. From Me To You was eventually released in stereo on 1973's 1962-1966 album, and in mono on 1988's Past Masters. Misery and There's A Place were released in stereo on 1980's Rarities and in mono when Please Please Me was released on CD in 1987.

The mono version of the album was simply a fake mono version of the stereo version of the album, which used the same UK stereo mixes as Please Please Me. Interestingly, Love Me Do and P.S. I Love You had never been mixed into true stereo. They were already in fake stereo on Please Please Me, so the versions of these two tracks on the mono The Early Beatles were fake mono mixes of fake stereo mixes of the original UK mono mixes. The true mono and stereo mixes of Please Please Me came from different takes, so the mono performance remained unavailable in the US until 1987's CD release of Please Please Me, along with the true mono mixes of the other tracks on Please Please Me.

Love Me Do
Mono: fake mono from fake stereo mix of 25 February 1963
Stereo: fake stereo from mono mix of 11 September 1962 (made 25 February 1963 by Parlophone)

Twist and Shout
Mono: fake mono from stereo mix of 25 February 1963
Stereo: stereo mix of 25 February 1963

Anna (Go to Him)
Mono: fake mono from stereo mix of 25 February 1963
Stereo: stereo mix of 25 February 1963

Chains
Mono: fake mono from stereo mix of 25 February 1963
Stereo: stereo mix of 25 February 1963

Boys
Mono: fake mono from stereo mix of 25 February 1963
Stereo: stereo mix of 25 February 1963

Ask Me Why
Mono: fake mono from stereo mix of 25 February 1963
Stereo: stereo mix of 25 February 1963

Please Please Me
Mono: fake mono from stereo mix of 25 February 1963
Stereo: from stereo mix of 25 February 1963

P.S. I Love You
Mono: fake mono from fake stereo mix of 25 February 1963
Stereo: fake stereo from mono mix of 11 September 1962 (made 25 February 1963 by Parlophone)

Baby It's You
Mono: fake mono from stereo mix of 25 February 1963
Stereo: stereo mix of 25 February 1963

A Taste of Honey
Mono: fake mono from stereo mix of 25 February 1963
Stereo: stereo mix of 25 February 1963

Do You Want to Know a Secret
Mono: fake mono from stereo mix of 25 February 1963
Stereo: stereo mix of 25 February 1963



Beatles VI

Beatles VI was released by Capitol in mono (T-2358) and stereo (ST-2358) on 14 June 1965.

Side One
1. Kansas City/Hey, Hey, Hey, Hey
2. Eight Days a Week
3. You Like Me Too Much
4. Bad Boy
5. I Don't Want to Spoil the Party
6. Words of Love

Side Two
1. What You're Doing
2. Yes It Is
3. Dizzy Miss Lizzy
4. Tell Me What You See
5. Every Little Thing



Capitol were finding it hard to keep up the momentum of their 1964 Beatles releases. The Early Beatles had plugged a gap, but with The Beatles busy working on their second feature film, new material was not forthcoming. Nevertheless they still had six tracks left over from Beatles For Sale, and Yes It Is, the B-side of The Beatles' recent single. Parlophone were able to supply You Like Me Too Much and Tell Me What You See - both rejects from the film soundtrack - but beyond that had no further new material available. Thus it was at Capitol's request that The Beatles went to Abbey Road on the evening of 10th May 1965, after a hard day's filming, to record their first songs specifically for the American market. For speed, they chose to perform two songs they knew well from their Hamburg days, Larry Williams' Bad Boy and Dizzy Miss Lizzy. For The Beatles, the pressure was beginning to show. Two of the songs from the Help! sessions were rejected as not good enough, and Dizzy Miss Lizzy was used to pad out the UK version of the album.

The mono version of Beatles VI used the same mixes as those that had been on the mono version of Beatles for Sale, that would appear later in the year on the UK mono version of Help!, or in the case of Bad Boy, would eventually be released on the mono version of 1966's A Collection of Beatles Oldies.

The stereo version of the album used the same stereo mixes as the UK as well, with the exception of Yes It Is, for which Capitol did not have a stereo mix, as it had been released as a single. Although the song had already been mixed into stereo back in the UK, Capitol chose to create a fake stereo version instead.

Kansas City/Hey-Hey-Hey-Hey!
Mono: from mono mix of 26 October 1964
Stereo: from stereo mix of 26 October 1964

Eight Days a Week
Mono: from mono mix of 27 October 1964
Stereo: from stereo mix of 27 October 1964

You Like Me Too Much
Mono: from mono mix of 18 February 1965
Stereo: from stereo mix of 23 February 1965

Bad Boy
Mono: from mono mix of 10 May 1965
Stereo: from stereo mix of 10 May 1965

I Don't Want to Spoil the Party
Mono: from mono mix of 26 October 1964
Stereo: from stereo mix of 4 November 1964

Words of Love
Mono: from mono mix of 26 October 1964
Stereo: from stereo mix of 4 November 1964

What You're Doing
Mono: from mono mix of 21 October 1964
Stereo: from stereo mix of 4 November 1964

Yes It Is
Mono: from mono mix of 28 February 1965
Stereo: fake stereo from mono mix of 28 February 1965

Dizzy Miss Lizzy
Mono: from mono mix of 10 May 1965
Stereo: from stereo mix of 10 May 1965

Tell Me What You See
Mono: from mono mix of 20 February 1965
Stereo: from stereo mix of 23 February 1965

Every Little Thing
Mono: from mono mix of 27 October 1964
Stereo: from stereo mix of 27 October 1964




Help! Original Soundtrack

Help!, the soundtrack to The Beatles' second feature film, was released by Capitol in mono (MAS-2386) and stereo (SMAS-2386) on 13 August 1965.

Side One
1. Help! (preceded by an uncredited instrumental intro)
2. The Night Before
3. From Me to You Fantasy (instrumental)
4. You've Got to Hide Your Love Away
5. I Need You
6. In the Tyrol (instrumental)

Side Two
1. Another Girl
2. Another Hard Day's Night (instrumental)
3. Ticket to Ride
4. Medley: The Bitter End /You Can't Do That (instrumental)
5. You're Going to Lose That Girl
6. The Chase (instrumental)

It featured the seven songs from the film, as featured on side one of the UK version of the album, interspersed with instrumental orchestral pieces from the soundtrack, written by Ken Thorne and conducted by George Martin. These instrumental pieces - notably the unnamed James Bond style intro to Help! and Another Hard Day's Night - inadvertently pointed in a new musical direction for The Beatles, featuring one of the first uses of a sitar on a pop album

The stereo version of the album used true stereo for all of the songs, except Ticket To Ride, which was a fake stereo mix created from the monophonic single.

The mono version of the album was simply a fake mono fold down of the stereo album, including the fake stereo Ticket To Ride.

Help!
Mono: fake mono from stereo mix of 23 February 1965
Stereo: from stereo mix of 18 June 1965

The Night Before
Mono: fake mono from stereo mix of 23 February 1965
Stereo: stereo mix of 23 February 1965

You've Got to Hide Your Love Away
Mono: fake mono from stereo mix of 23 February 1965
Stereo: stereo mix of 23 February 1965

I Need You
Mono: fake mono from stereo mix of 23 February 1965
Stereo: stereo mix of 23 February 1965

Another Girl
Mono: fake mono from stereo mix of 23 February 1965
Stereo: stereo mix of 23 February 1965

Ticket to Ride
Mono: fake mono from fake stereo from mono mix of 18 February 1965
Stereo: fake stereo from mono mix of 18 February 1965

You're Going to Lose That Girl
Mono: fake mono from stereo mix of 23 February 1965
Stereo: from stereo mix of 23 February 1965




Rubber Soul

The US version of Rubber Soul was released by Capitol in mono (T-2442) and stereo (ST-2442) on 6 December 1965.

Side One
1. I've Just Seen a Face
2. Norwegian Wood (This Bird Has Flown)
3. You Won't See Me
4. Think for Yourself
5. The Word
6. Michelle

Side Two
1. It's Only Love
2. Girl
3. I'm Looking Through You
4. In My Life
5. Wait
6. Run for Your Life


This is the only one of Dave Dexter's US Beatles compilations which general consensus says equals or betters it's UK version. Dexter still had five songs left over from side two of the UK Help!  album, and he used two of them here, with I've Just Seen A Face kicking off side one, and It's Only Love doing the same on side two. He also chose to drop four of the songs from the UK version of Rubber Soul , taking the track count to 12. The album had a more acoustic feel than the UK version, and place The Beatles within the American "folk-rock" movement. The album's influence on Brian Wilson of The Beach Boys was such that he created his masterpiece, Pet Sounds , in order to better it.

The mono version of the album used the same mono mixes as were released in the UK, except for Michelle, which used an earlier mix.

The stereo version of the album used the same stereo mixes as the UK, except for The Word, which again used an earlier mix. Although I'm Looking Through You used the same mix as the UK, it includes a false start. As was his custom, Dexter also added a layer of reverb to the stereo version of the album, but erroneously sent a version without reverb to the pressing plant in LA. So there were two versions of the stereo album released - one with reverb (the "East Coast" version) and one without.

Perhaps because of this error, Rubber Soul was Dave Dexter Jr.'s final work on The Beatles albums.

I've Just Seen a Face
Mono: mono mix of 18 June 1965
Stereo: stereo mix of 18 June 1965

Norwegian Wood (This Bird Has Flown)
Mono: mono mix of 25 October 1965
Stereo: stereo mix of 26 October 1965

You Won't See Me
Mono: mono mix of 15 November 1965
Stereo: stereo mix of 15 November 1965

Think for Yourself
Mono: mono mix of 9 November 1965
Stereo: stereo mix of 9 November 1965

The Word
Mono: mono mix of 11 November 1965
Stereo: US exclusive stereo mix of 11 November 1965

Michelle
Mono: US exclusive mono mix of 9 November 1965
Stereo: from stereo mix of 9 November 1965

It's Only Love
Mono: mono mix of 18 June 1965
Stereo: stereo mix of 18 June 1965

Girl
Mono: mono mix of 15 November 1965
Stereo: stereo mix of 15 November 1965

I'm Looking Through You
Mono: mono mix of 15 November 1965
Stereo: stereo mix of 15 November 1965 (but includes false start)

In My Life
Mono: mono mix of 25 October 1965
Stereo: stereo mix of 26 October 1965

Wait
Mono: mono mix of 15 November 1965
Stereo: stereo mix of 15 November 1965

Run for Your Life
Mono: mono mix of 9 November 1965
Stereo: stereo mix of 10 November 1965



Yesterday and Today

Yesterday And Today was issued by Capitol in mono (T-2553) and stereo (ST-2553) on 15 June 1966, with artwork from a photo by Bob Whitaker. The photo showed The Beatles dressed as butchers, surrounded by raw meat and dismembered dolls, and many retailers refused point blank to stock it. The album was quickly withdrawn, and reissued hurriedly on 20 June 1966, with a much safer photo, also by Whitaker.

Side One
1. Drive My Car
2. I'm Only Sleeping
3. Nowhere Man
4. Doctor Robert
5. Yesterday
6. Act Naturally

Side Two
1. And Your Bird Can Sing
2. If I Needed Someone
3. We Can Work It Out
4. What Goes On
5. Day Tripper



After a brief UK tour to promote Rubber Soul, The Beatles had taken three months off - their longest break since their days as The Quarrymen back in Liverpool - then started work on a new album. Rubber Soul had been a rushed album, recorded quickly in October and November 1965, and released in time for Christmas. The Beatles were determined to take their time over the next album. But as in the previous year, Capitol wanted to release new Beatles material, and with The Beatles spending longer than ever in the studio, there was little forthcoming. There were some singles kicking about that had not yet been released on an album: Yesterday / Act Naturally had been released in September 1965, We Can Work It Out / Day Tripper in December 1965, Nowhere Man / What Goes On in February 1966 and Paperback Writer / Rain in May 1966. Also awaiting an album release was I'm Down, the B-side of Help! back in July 1965. These nine songs, along with the remaining two unreleased tracks from Rubber Soul, Drive My Car and If I Needed Someone, could have been compiled into an eleven track album.

Yesterday and Today (or "Yesterday"...and Today, to give it it's correct title) was compiled by Bill Miller. Deciding that there was little value in releasing an album containing nine songs that fans already owned, Miller opted to drop Paperback Writer, Rain and I'm Down. This left him three songs short, so he contacted George Martin and asked if there was any new material that he could have. Martin agreed, and mixed three tracks from The Beatles work-in-progress into mono and stereo for Miller.

The mono version of Yesterday and Today used the same mono mixes as the UK, with the exception of the three new tracks mixed at Capitol's request, I'm Only Sleeping, Doctor Robert and And Your Bird Can Sing. These would all receive new mono mixes before their UK release. A fake mono version of Drive My Car was also created, even though a true mono mix was available.

The stereo version of the album again uses mostly the UK stereo mixes. Despite being released only as a mono single, We Can Work It Out and Day Tripper had been mixed into stereo during the Rubber Soul sessions, in case The Beatles did not manage enough new material during the hurried recording of that album, and these stereo mixes were supplied to Capitol. New stereo mixes of these two songs would be prepared for their UK stereo release, on 1966's A Collection Of Beatles Oldies. Martin had created true stereo mixes of I'm Only SleepingDoctor Robert and And Your Bird Can Sing a week after the mono versions, but by the time they arrived in the US, Miller had already created fake stereo versions. Some, but not all, later reissues of the album (post 1973) used the US exclusive stereo mixes. Stereo 2 below refers to the reissued album.

Drive My Car
Mono: fake mono from stereo mix of 26 October 1965
Stereo: stereo mix of 26 October 1965

I'm Only Sleeping
Mono: US exclusive mono mix of 12 May 1966
Stereo 1: fake stereo from mono mix of 12 May 1966
Stereo 2: US exclusive stereo mix of 20 May 1966
Nowhere Man
Mono: mono mix of 25 October 1965
Stereo: stereo mix of 26 October 1965

Doctor Robert
Mono: US exclusive mono mix of 12 May 1966
Stereo 1: fake stereo from mono mix of 12 May 1966
Stereo 2: US exclusive stereo mix of 20 May 1966

Yesterday
Mono: mono mix of 17 June 1965
Stereo: stereo mix of 18 June 1965

Act Naturally
Mono: mono mix of 18 June 1965
Stereo: stereo mix of 18 June 1965

And Your Bird Can Sing
Mono: US exclusive mono mix of 12 May 1966
Stereo 1: fake stereo from mono mix of 12 May 1966
Stereo 2: US exclusive stereo mix of 20 May 1966

If I Needed Someone
Mono: mono mix of 25 October 1965
Stereo: stereo mix of 26 October 1965

We Can Work It Out
Mono: mono mix of 29 October 1965
Stereo: US exclusive stereo mix of 10 November 1965

What Goes On
Mono: mono mix of 9 November 1965
Stereo: stereo mix of 9 November 1965

Day Tripper
Mono: mono mix of 29 October 1965
Stereo: US exclusive stereo mix of 26 October 1965



Revolver

Revolver was issued by Capitol in mono (T-2576) and stereo (ST-2576) on 8 August 1966. Artwork was from a black and white drawing and photo collage by The Beatles' old friend from their Hamburg days, Klaus Voormann.

Side One
1. Taxman
2. Eleanor Rigby
3. Love You To
4. Here, There And Everywhere
5. Yellow Submarine
6. She Said, She Said

Side Two
1. Good Day Sunshine
2. For No One
3. I Want To Tell You
4. Got To Get You Into My Life
5. Tomorrow Never Knows



Both mono and stereo versions of the album were the same as their UK equivalents, although missing the three songs already released on Yesterday and Today.

This was the last occasion on which a UK and US album would differ. The Beatles recording contract with EMI expired after it's release, and while they were happy to sign a new contract, effective from 27 January 1967, they insisted that their albums were released worldwide in the way in which they intended.

Taxman
Mono: from mono mix of 21 June 1966
Stereo: from stereo mix of 21 June 1966

Eleanor Rigby
Mono: from mono mix of 22 June 1966
Stereo: from stereo mix of 22 June 1966

Love You To
Mono: from mono mix of 13 April 1966
Stereo: from stereo mix of 21 June 1966

Here, There and Everywhere
Mono: from mono mix of 21 June 1966
Stereo: from stereo mix of 21 June 1966

Yellow Submarine
Mono: from mono mix of 3 June 1966
Stereo: from stereo mix of 21 June 1966

She Said She Said
Mono: from mono mix of 22 June 1966
Stereo: from stereo mix of 22 June 1966

Good Day Sunshine
Mono: from mono mix of 22 June 1966
Stereo: from stereo mix of 22 June 1966

For No One
Mono: from mono mix of 21 June 1966
Stereo: from stereo mix of 21 June 1966

I Want to Tell You
Mono: from mono mix of 3 June 1966
Stereo: from stereo mix of 21 June 1966

Got to Get You into My Life
Mono: from mono mix of 20th June 1966
Stereo: from stereo mix of 22 June 1966

Tomorrow Never Knows
Mono: from mono mix of 6 June 1966
Stereo: from stereo mix of 22 June 1966



Magical Mystery Tour

Magical Mystery Tour was released by Capitol in mono (MAL-2835) and stereo (SMAL-2835) on 27 November 1967.

Side 1
1. Magical Mystery Tour
2. The Fool on the Hill
3. Flying
4. Blue Jay Way
5. Your Mother Should Know
6. I Am the Walrus

Side 2
1. Hello, Goodbye
2. Strawberry Fields Forever
3. Penny Lane
4. Baby, You're a Rich Man
5. All You Need Is Love



The soundtrack to The Beatles third film, Magical Mystery Tour, had been released in the UK as a mono and stereo double EP set. However, the EP was not a popular format in the US, so Capitol decided to add The Beatles 1967 singles and release an album instead. The album was compiled by Voyle Gilmore.

The mono version of the album used the same mono mixes as the UK singles and mono EP, although a slightly longer version of I Am The Walrus had appeared as the B-side to Hello Goodbye in the US. This had then been edited in the US to match the UK version before being released on the album.

The stereo version of the album used the same stereo mixes as the UK stereo Magical Mystery Tour EP, again with the exception of I Am The Walrus, which used an earlier stereo mix. Strawberry Fields Forever had been mixed to stereo for inclusion on Sgt.Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band, but had been issued as a single. It made its stereo debut here. This version would later appear on 1973's 1967-1970 album. Hello Goodbye was also mixed to stereo specifically for the American market, and would also not appear in the UK until 1973's 1967-1970 album. No stereo mixes of Penny Lane, Baby, You're A Rich Man or All You Need Is Love were available, so Capitol created fake stereo versions of these tracks.

The stereo Magical Mystery Tour LP was released in the UK in 1976. Newer stereo mixes were used for both I Am The Walrus and Strawberry Fields Forever. This has been the standard version since then, including the CD releases of the album.

Magical Mystery Tour
Mono: mono mix of 7 November 1967
Stereo: stereo mix of 7 November 1967

The Fool on the Hill
Mono: mono mix of 25 October 1967
Stereo: stereo mix of 1 November 1967

Flying
Mono: mono mix of 28 September 1967
Stereo: stereo mix of 7 November 1967

Blue Jay Way
Mono: mono mix of 7 November 1967
Stereo: stereo mix of 7 November 1967

Your Mother Should Know
Mono: mono mix of 2 October 1967
Stereo: stereo mix  of 6 November 1967

I Am the Walrus
Mono: mono mix of 29 September 1967
Stereo: US exclusive stereo mix of 6 November 1967

Hello, Goodbye
Mono: mono mix of 6 November 1967
Stereo: stereo mix of 6 November 1967

Strawberry Fields Forever
Mono: mono mix of 22 December 1966
Stereo: US exclusive stereo mix of 29 December 1966

Penny Lane
Mono: mono mix of 25 January 1967
Stereo: fake stereo from mono mix of 25 January 1967

Baby, You're a Rich Man
Mono: mono mix of 11 May 1967
Stereo: fake stereo from mono mix of 11 May 1967

All You Need Is Love
Mono: mono mix of 26 June 1967
Stereo: fake stereo from mono mix of 26 June 1967




Hey Jude

Hey Jude was released by Capitol in stereo only (SW-385) on 26 February 1970.

Side 1
1. Can't Buy Me Love
2. I Should Have Known Better
3. Paperback Writer
4. Rain
5. Lady Madonna
6. Revolution

Side 2
1. Hey Jude
2. Old Brown Shoe
3. Don't Let Me Down
4. The Ballad of John and Yoko





Although a US release, Hey Jude album was not compiled by Capitol, but by Allan Steckler of Bell Sounds, New York, working directly for Apple, The Beatles' own record label, under the direction of Allan Klien, The Beatles' manager.

Steckler chose to include songs which had so far not been released on an album by Capitol. As a consequence of The Beatles' 1967 contract with EMI forbidding Capitol from carving up their albums, there was plenty to choose from. Their 1967 output had already been compiled into the Magical Mystery Tour album, but there had been no such compilation since. There were also a number of earlier tracks which had fallen by the wayside.

By this criteria, Steckler could have made a double album by including:

  • Misery
  • There's a Place
  • From Me to You
  • Sie Liebt Dich
  • A Hard Day's Night
  • I'm Down
  • The Inner Light
  • Across The Universe (Our World mix)
  • Get Back (single mix)
As most of the earlier tracks were singles they had been mixed and released in mono only, so they were mixed to stereo for this album at the beginning of December 1969. In 1969, Capitol had started to release singles in stereo, so stereo mixes were already available for Old Brown Shoe, Don't Let Me Down and The Ballad Of John And Yoko. The original 1964 stereo mixes were used for the two tracks from A Hard Day's Night, Can't Buy Me Love and I Should Have Known Better. Paperback Writer used the same stereo mix that had previously appeared in the UK on A Collection Of Beatles Oldies, but due to an error, the left and right channels were reversed.

At the time of release, all of the 1969 mixes were US exclusives, but they have since become the standard stereo mixes for these tracks, and have been released, for example, on Past Masters.

Can't Buy Me Love
Stereo: stereo mix of 26 February 1964

I Should Have Known Better
Stereo: stereo mix of 22 June 1964

Paperback Writer
Stereo: stereo mix of 31 October 1966

Rain
Stereo: stereo mix of 2 December 1969

Lady Madonna
Stereo: stereo mix of 2 December 1969

Revolution
Stereo: stereo mix of 5 December 1969

Hey Jude
Stereo: stereo mix of 5 December 1969

Old Brown Shoe
Stereo: stereo mix of 18 April 1969

Don't Let Me Down
Stereo: stereo mix of 7 April 1969

The Ballad of John and Yoko
Stereo: stereo mix of 14 April 1969



Monday, 14 October 2013

Ask Me Why: When Was The Beatles First Audition At Abbey Road

George Martin
On page 16 of his 1988 book, The Complete Beatles Recording Sessions, author Mark Lewisohn states that The Beatles first set foot in Abbey Road on Wednesday 6th June 1962. Also according to Lewisohn, on page 56 of his 1992 book The Complete Beatles Chronicle, EMI paperwork shows that George Martin had offered The Beatles a contract following a meeting with Brian Epstein on Wednesday 9th May 1962 without first seeing them play, and without having met them. His decision was allegedly based only on hearing their failed Decca audition, and Epstein's insistence that his band were going to be "bigger than Elvis". The Beatles contract, dated 4th June 1962, still exists.

These dates have been taken as gospel ever since, with the somewhat romantic notion of Martin blindly signing the Beatles passing into legend.

However, is this really likely? In fact, George Martin himself has addressed the issue:
George Martin: I signed The Beatles on 4 June 1962: the original contract still exists with that date on it. I would never, ever, have offered a contract to Brian Epstein for a group I had not met, or heard live. Yet most versions of events state that the first Beatles audition - and thus our first meeting - did not take place until 6 June. But this, according to the contract, was two days after I had signed the group for three years!

I don't think it was quite like that. My memory is of a recording audition in No.3 studio, at EMI Abbey Road (the upstairs studio), in March 1962. This memory is backed up by my wife, Judy Lockhart Smith.
(Source:  Summer of Love: The Making of Sgt. Pepper, George Martin with William Pearson, Macmillan London Ltd., 1994, p32)
A quick glance at Lewisohn's Chronicle shows that The Beatles were busy throughout March 1962, mostly playing clubs round Liverpool, but also including their radio debut. The only date that they had free was on Tuesday 27 March.

This suggests that this was the date that Martin is recalling above. This is corroborated by a letter that Epstein wrote to Bert Kaempfert that same day:
As it happens the particular recording Company with whom we have negotiated are unable to record the group until they return from Germany and in any event prefer to wait until their existing contract with yourself has expired.

In the circumstances therefore I would like to give you formal notice of our wish to terminate the contract at the end of this contractual period (30th June 1962).

With regard to their recording when in Germany I would myself be very pleased to discuss this with you as I shall be arriving in Hamburg on April 9th - a few days in advance of the group. I will, therefore contact you then and possibly we can settle details of their actual recording sessions.
(Source: The Complete Beatles ChronicleMark Lewisohn, Octopus 1992 (page 54) )
This suggests that the version of events on Tuesday 27 March 1962 was that the Beatles auditioned for EMI in Abbey Road Studio 3, with no recording or paperwork. Following discussion with George Martin, in which he decides to bring them in for a recording audition, it becomes clear that he cannot record them until they have completed their contract with Kaempfert. That evening, Epstein writes to Kaempfert to extricate his charges from their German contract.

Martin, meanwhile, begins preparation of the necessary paperwork, should the recording audition be successful.

For full details of the Beatles' signing, qv Brian Epstein Negotiates Beatles Deal With Parlophone.


Sunday, 15 September 2013

Ask Me Why: When Did Bob Wooler Acquire His Copy Of "My Bonnie"

On page 34 of The Complete Beatles Chronicle,  Mark Lewisohn states that George Harrison gave Bob Wooler a copy of My Bonnie one Saturday night in August 1961 on a bus en route for the Aintree Institute. However, the single was not released in Germany until Monday, 23 October 1961, a whole two months later. So at what point did Bob Wooler acquire the copy of My Bonnie that led to Raymond Jones asking Brian Epstein to order the single for NEMS on Saturday, 28 October 1961, just five days after the single's German release.
Bob Wooler: "My Bonnie" came into my possession because I happened to get on the same bus one Saturday night as George Harrison. He said, "Look at this. I've just received it today." Stuart Sutcliffe, who had stayed behind in Hamburg the second time around, had sent him a copy of the record they had recorded for Bert Kaempfert in the spring of 1961. I grabbed it and said I was working the Aintree Institute that night. They weren't playing on that bill. They were playing the lower ballroom in New Brighton, and I said, "Let me play it tonight because you're playing the Aintree next weekend and this will be great promotion." George wanted to hang on to it because the others hadn't seen it, let alone heard it. But I said, "Look, we'll all be meeting up tomorrow night at Hambleton Hall, so I'll bring it there and play it. Then you can have it back and loan it to me again for the Cavern lunchtime sessions," which I was hosting. So he let me have it, and the first play of the record, outside George's record player, was at Aintree Institute.

(Source: The Beatles: An Oral History David Pritchard & Alan Lysaght,Stoddart Publishing Co., 1998, pp72-73)
There are a couple of anomalies in Wooler's statement:
  • The Beatles recorded My Bonnie on 22 or 23 June 1961, not in the spring. (qv The Hamburg Tapes)
  • The Beatles did not play the lower ballroom in New Brighton until Friday, 10 November 1961 - two weeks after Raymond Jones asked Epstein for the record.

However, we can take a couple of points as assumed fact, there being nothing to the contrary:
  • It was a Saturday night, but The Beatles were not playing at Aintree Institute that night. The Beatles played the Aintree Institute every Saturday night from 12 August 1961 until 23 September 1961.
  • The Beatles were going to be at Hambleton Hall the following night

Wooler's statement also raises another question:
  • Why did Stuart Sutcliffe send the single to George Harrison, not his best friend, John Lennon?
This last point is important, because it raises a further question: Where was John Lennon?

The Beatles played Hambleton Hall on Sunday, 15 October 1961. They had not played at the Aintree Institute on 30 September or 7 or 14 October 1961 because Lennon and McCartney had gone on holiday to Paris to meet their friend Jurgen Volmer on 30 September. It is reasonable to assume that Sutcliffe, who was still friends with Tony Sheridan, had managed to get hold of an advance copy of the single a couple of weeks before its official release and had sent it on to The Beatles back in Liverpool. Knowing that Lennon and McCartney were in Paris with Volmer, he sent it instead to George Harrison. Harrison received it on 14 October 1961, by which time Lennon and McCartney were back in Liverpool.

So Wooler got his copy of My Bonnie from George Harrison on a bus on Saturday, 14 October 1961

In fact, The Beatles were next due at Aintree Institute on Saturday, 28 October 1961, two weeks after this date. They next played Hambleton Hall on Sunday, 29 October 1961.


Brian Epstein Becomes The Beatles' Manager

The single that the Beatles had recorded with Tony Sheridan in Hamburg, My Bonnie (Mein Herz ist bei dir nur)/The Saints (Polydor NH 24673), was issued in Germany on Monday, 23 October 1961, credited to Tony Sheridan & The Beat Brothers (qv The Hamburg Tapes). Their former bass player, Stuart Sutcliffe, who had remained in Hamburg with his fiancée Astrid Kirchherr, lost no time in sending advance copies to The Beatles back in Liverpool.[1] He sent them to George Harrison, as John Lennon and Paul McCartney had taken themselves off on a trip to Paris. Harrison received the record on Saturday, 14 October 1961 (qv Ask Me Why: When Did Bob Wooler Acquire His Copy Of "My Bonnie"). Ironically, Lennon and McCartney had returned earlier in the week after running out of money.

Bob Wooler, the Disc Jockey
at the Cavern Club and a friend
of The Beatles
Later that day, on the bus on his way to show the other Beatles the record, Harrison bumped into Bob Wooler, a local compère and disc jockey who worked at the Cavern Club, and who had his own show at Hambleton Hall on Friday nights. Wooler worked regularly with The Beatles, and mentioned them often in his column, “The Roving I,” which he wrote for the local pop newspaper, Mersey Beat.

Prior to Lennon and McCartney’s holiday, The Beatles had been playing the Aintree Institute every Saturday night, with Wooler as compère. While they were away, Wooler was working at the Aintree Institute as a disk jockey on Saturday nights. He persuaded a reluctant Harrison to lend him the record, which he intended playing to promote the Beatles’ return to the venue on the 28th October, 1961. So it was that The Beatles’ first single was first played in public in the UK at the Aintree Institute by Bob Wooler on Saturday, 14 October 1961. Wooler promised Harrison that he would return the record when The Beatles played at Hambleton Hall the following evening, but instead he hung on to the record, playing it at every available opportunity and urging people to order the disc from their local record shop. As The Beatles friend, Wooler was hoping that a British record company could be persuaded to release the single.

Among the crowd when Wooler played the record at Hambleton Hall on Friday, 27 October 1961 was an 18 year old boy from Huyton named Raymond Jones. The following day, Jones did exactly as Wooler had instructed, and went into NEMS record store, at 12-14 Whitechapel, Liverpool to order a copy of the single. He was served by 27-year old store manager Brian Epstein.[2]

According to Epstein in his autobiography, A Cellarful of Noise, he had never heard of The Beatles before Jones asked for the record. This is not entirely true.  Like Bob Wooler, Epstein wrote for Mersey Beat, in this case a record review column called “Stop The World – And Listen To Everything In It”.[3] Bill Harry, the editor of Mersey Beat, had shared a flat with John Lennon in Gambier Terrace, and attended Liverpool College of Art with Lennon and Stuart Sutcliffe. As such, The Beatles were given heavy exposure within the pages of Harry's newspaper, which was sold in Epstein's shop and which Epstein must have read.

The line up for Jim Gretty's charity show at the
Albany Cinema, Northway, Maghull
Epstein had been initially surprised by Mersey Beat's revelation that there was such a burgeoning rock 'n' roll scene right on his doorstep that he had not previously been aware of. Sales of Mersey Beat in NEMS were going through the roof, and Epstein began calling Harry two or three times a week to discuss the Liverpool scene. A vague idea began to germinate in his mind that he might manage one of these bands.

He approached Jim Gretty, a salesman and guitar teacher at Hessey's Music Store, a few doors down from NEMS, and quizzed him about local bands. Gretty listed Gerry Marsden, The Fourmost, The Beatles and Rory Storm as the best, and invited Epstein along to a variety show he had organised at the Albany Cinema in Maghull on the afternoon 15 October 1961, in aid of the local branch of the St.John Ambulance Brigade.

The Beatles appeared tenth on a sixteen act bill, kicking off the second half of the show following the interval. Epstein sat in the audience alongside the local mayor, councillors and various civic dignitaries. Gretty had managed to secure well known local comedian Ken Dodd to top the bill. Dodd remembers:
I got there about 3p.m., and there was chaos. People were walking out because some idiots on stage were making the most terrible row. I said to the producer, "You've got to get these fellers off, they're killing the show." They got them off, and while I was changing, one of these idiots came in and said, "Somebody told me that if we gave you our card, you might be able to get us a few bookings." I threw the card away. Later on, when I worked with The Beatles, Paul McCartney said, "We've worked with you before, Doddy." I replied, "No, you've never worked with me, lad." He said "Yes, we have, at the Albany, Maghull." I asked him "That noise wasn't you, was it?" and he said, "Yeah, we were rubbish, weren't we?" to which I replied, "You certainly were. I had you thrown off."
(Source: The Beatles in Liverpool: The Stories, the Scene, and the Path to Stardom Spencer Leigh, Omnibus Press, 2012 (p76))
It was not a good advert for The Beatles. They were unsuitable for both the other acts and for the audience. Nevertheless, Epstein went back to Gretty the following Monday, telling him, "Jim, I like those Beatles. I'd like to manage them."[4]

Posters for Operation Big Beat
were prominently displayed at NEMS
for at least a week before Raymond
Jones came into the store.
By the time Raymond Jones came into NEMS looking for The Beatles' single, Epstein could not have failed to be aware of them. The Beatles were regular customers, and local promoter Sam Leach had arranged for NEMS to advertise and sell tickets to Operation Big Beat, a promotion that he was putting on at the Tower Ballroom on Friday 10 November 1961. Posters featuring The Beatles as the band at the top of the bill were plastered all over NEMS.[5]

NEMS advertised itself as “The Finest Record Selection in the North”. Epstein had a policy that no customer request should ever be turned down. If a record was not in stock then it would be ordered. My Bonnie, being a German release, naturally was not in stock, and it was left to Epstein's assistant, Alistair Taylor, to track it down. The Monday after Jones had requested the record, two girls also came in looking for it. The Beatles' record was certainly not listed in the industry publication, Record Retailer. Although Epstein by now was well aware of The Beatles, he was not aware that their single had not been released in their name, but was instead credited to Tony Sheridan and The Beat Brothers.

Following up on the idea that had now been at the back of his mind for some months, Epstein contacted Bill Harry at Mersey Beat, and arranged a visit to the Cavern. He figured that the best way to track down the record was to ask The Beatles themselves. So it was that, on the lunchtime of Thursday 9th November 1961, Brian Epstein and Alistair Taylor walked into the Cavern Club, dressed in their smart business suits. Any attempt at anonymity was lost when Bob Wooler announced Epstein's presence over the PA.
Alistair Taylor: There was this very scruffy band onstage in black leather and black T-shirts. They were fooling about and they weren't very good musicians. But it was the most phenomenal experience I've ever gone through. They were incredible! They just had charisma. Lots of artists have charisma, but they had Ingredient X. You could literally feel the sound hitting you, pounding against your chest.
(Source: The Beatles: An Oral History David Pritchard & Alan Lysaght, Hyperion, 1998 (p83))
At the interval, Epstein and Taylor went round to the band room. The first person they met was George Harrison, who enquired, "What brings Mr Epstein here?"

What brought Mr Epstein to the Cavern was to find out about the record that The Beatles had released. Epstein explained about the demand for their record, got the answers that he was looking for, heard Wooler play the record, then left.[6] Epstein and Taylor went to lunch, where Epstein explained to Taylor that he was toying with the idea of managing The Beatles. A new company would have to set up to manage their affairs, and he offered Taylor a two and a half percent stake, which Taylor turned down, figuring he would be better off drawing a salary from the company.

A box of 25 copies of My Bonnie were duly ordered from Polydor in Germany. All 25 sold out in around half an hour, and Epstein ordered a further 250. Realising the popularity of The Beatles, and concerned at the import costs, Taylor contacted Polydor in London, to try to organise a UK pressing of the single, but to no avail.

Epstein saw The Beatles play several time over the course of November, and in the meantime quizzed his contacts in the record industry about the relationship between groups and managers. He even visited The Blue Angel Club and spoke to The Beatles' former manager, Allan Williams, who had arranged their Hamburg trips for them, and to whom The Beatles still owed commision. Williams' advice was "don't touch The Beatles with a bargepole".[7]

Eventually, a formal meeting was arranged to take place at NEMS at 4:30pm on Sunday 3 December 1961. The Beatles had been playing The Casbah Coffee Club that lunchtime. They had arranged to go via The Cavern to pick up Bob Wooler, who they trusted implicitly to advise them in their meeting with Epstein. Arriving late after they took a detour via The Grapes, they found Epstein waiting on the darkened ground floor of NEMS. Epstein, a stickler for punctuality, was annoyed. but hid it well, asking what Wooler was doing there. "This is me dad," Lennon replied.

Epstein put it to The Beatles that he would like to be their manager. However, they would not commit themselves at this point, and Epstein left them to think it over for a few days. In the meantime, he spoke to the Epstein family solicitor, E Rex Makin, looking for some legal advice on the sort of contract he might offer The Beatles. Makin had known Epstein for his whole life, and was sceptical about the idea, convinced the he would lose interest before too long.

But Epstein was not to be discouraged. He met with The Beatles again on Wednesday 6 December at NEMS, and put his conditions to The Beatles. He would require 25% of their gross fees each week. In return, he would organise all of their bookings. He also stated that they would never play for less than £15 per date, except for the lunchtime sessions at The Cavern, for which he would double their fee from £5 to £10. Finally, he played his trump card. He would negotiate their withdrawal from their recording contract with Bert Kaempfert, and use his influence to get The Beatles a recording contract with a major British recording company.[8]

After a brief but awkward silence while The Beatles contemplated Brian's proposal, McCartney asked if Epstein would influence the music that they played. Epstein assured him that it would not. After another short silence, Lennon spoke up on behalf of the group.

"Right then, Brian. Manage us."

Another meeting was held at The Casbah Coffee Club, in the basement of Pete Best's home, on Sunday 10 December, 1961. Epstein presented them with a contract that he had drawn up. It is a measure of the man that he had sourced a typical management contract, and had been so disgusted by its mean and exploitative content that he had created his own much fairer version instead. All four Beatles agreed in principle to the contract, subject to Epstein putting his side of the bargain into action.

The management contract was eventually signed by all four Beatles in the NEMS office after their lunchtime session at The Cavern on Wednesday 24 January 1962, by which time Epstein had secured them an audition with Decca Records (see The Decca Audition). Epstein himself didn't sign until October 1962, by which time The Beatles were set to release their debut UK single for Parlophone.

[1] The Beatles: An Oral History David Pritchard & Alan Lysaght - p72-73 
[2] Shout! The Beatles in Their Generation Philip Norman - p125 
[3] The Ultimate Beatles Encyclopedia  Bill Harry - p762 
[4] The Beatles: An Oral History David Pritchard & Alan Lysaght - Page 77 
[5] The Ultimate Beatles Encyclopedia  Bill Harry - p384 
[6] The Complete Beatles Chronicle  Mark Lewisohn - Page 35 
[7] Shout! The Beatles in Their Generation Philip Norman - p130 
[8] The Complete Beatles Chronicle  Mark Lewisohn - Page 36